Author
Marcus PetrovicDirector & Head of Client Strategy
Jack’s pub was still busy on weekends. Staff were still getting rostered on. Suppliers still needed to be paid. But behind the bar, the debt was getting out of control.
The business owed close to $950,000 across business loans, credit cards, GST debt, and unpaid superannuation. Every month the ATO debt grew larger, cash flow got tighter, and the pressure on the business kept building. Jack thought he was heading towards Liquidation.
Instead, the business entered a Small Business Restructure and reduced the debt down to a manageable repayment arrangement that allowed the pub to keep trading. The key was moving early enough before the debt climbed beyond the eligibility threshold.
That part matters more than most directors realise. A business can be under serious pressure and still have options available, but those options can disappear quickly if the situation keeps drifting.
How Debt Starts Snowballing in Hospitality Businesses
Hospitality businesses can get into trouble fast when costs rise and cash flow slows down. One quiet trading period turns into three. Food costs increase. Supplier accounts start stretching out. BAS debt gets pushed aside to cover wages and rent. Credit cards get used to plug short-term gaps. Then the interest starts piling up on top of everything else.
That was what happened here. Jack’s debt had spread across:
- business loans
- credit cards
- unpaid GST
- superannuation liabilities
The pub was still trading, but the business was behind on almost everything. Some weeks were spent deciding which bills could wait another few days just to keep enough cash in the account for payroll and supplier payments.
Jack wanted to know whether there was still a realistic way to keep the business operating while dealing with the debt properly. That led to two possible options:
- a Small Business Restructure
- a Voluntary Administration
Both are formal insolvency processes. Both can stop creditors from escalating recovery action while the business works through its financial position. But they work very differently once the process starts.
How a Small Business Restructure Works
A Small Business Restructure is designed for eligible small businesses that need time to sort out debt without shutting the doors. The director stays in control of the company while a restructuring practitioner helps put together a proposal for creditors. That proposal sets out:
- what the business can realistically afford to repay
- how repayments will be made
- how long the arrangement will run for
If creditors vote to accept the proposal, the remaining debt is compromised under the agreement. For many directors, the biggest advantage is that the business can keep trading while the debt gets sorted out. That is one of the biggest differences compared to a Voluntary Administration. Mackay Goodwin explains the process further in their guide to Small Business Restructuring.
When a Voluntary Administration Is the Better Option
A Voluntary Administration is generally more suitable for larger or more complicated businesses. Once a company enters Voluntary Administration, an external administrator takes control of the business and reviews the company’s financial position. Creditors then vote on what should happen next. That may involve:
- handing control back to directors
- entering into a Deed of Company Arrangement
- moving the company into Liquidation
There are situations where a Voluntary Administration makes far more sense than a Small Business Restructure. For example:
- legal disputes
- difficult shareholder issues
- complicated company structures
- major creditor disputes
- contracts that need formal review
In those situations, directors are often already overwhelmed trying to keep the business alive day to day. Handing control to an experienced administrator can remove some of that pressure and allow the situation to be dealt with properly. A Voluntary Administration also does not have the same eligibility criteria attached to it. You can read more in Mackay Goodwin’s guide to Voluntary Administration.
Why Timing Became So Important
In Jack’s case, timing was critical. To qualify for a Small Business Restructure, businesses need to meet several eligibility requirements, including:
- total liabilities under $1 million
- tax lodgements up to date
- employee entitlements that are due and payable generally need to be addressed, including superannuation
- no prior Simplified Liquidation or Small Business Restructure within the previous seven years
- the business is insolvent or likely to become insolvent
Eligibility for a Small Business Restructure depends on the company’s full circumstances, not just whether debts sit below the $1 million threshold. Jack’s debt was already sitting close to the limit. If the business had continued trading for another six months without dealing with the problem, the interest charges and penalties would likely have pushed the debt beyond the threshold.
This is where a lot of directors run into trouble. They spend months trying to push through the pressure while tax debt quietly continues building in the background. By the time they finally speak with an Insolvency Practitioner, some restructuring options may no longer be available.
The Business Had to Clear the Super Debt First
Before the restructuring process could move forward, there was another issue that had to be fixed. The business had unpaid superannuation debt. Under the Small Business Restructure rules, employee entitlements that are due and payable generally need to be addressed before the company can proceed with the process.
We see this a lot with small businesses under pressure. Directors prioritise wages, suppliers, rent, and stock because they are trying to keep the business operating week to week. Superannuation falls behind while everything else gets juggled. For accountants with hospitality clients, unpaid super and rising ATO debt are warning signs that restructuring advice should be sought early.
The problem is that unpaid super can also expose directors personally through a Director Penalty Notice. The ATO explains director obligations and superannuation responsibilities further on the Australian Taxation Office website.
To make the business eligible, Jack secured funding to clear the outstanding superannuation debt before the restructuring proposal was lodged. That gave the business a chance to move before the debt position became worse.
Reducing the Debt by 78%
Once the company became eligible, a restructuring proposal was presented to creditors. The proposal offered creditors 22 cents in the dollar. That reduced the original debt of around $950,000 by roughly 78%, leaving the business with a far more manageable repayment arrangement moving forward.
The remaining balance would then be repaid monthly over an 18 month period. For Jack, the difference was immediate. Instead of spending every week fielding creditor calls, worrying about ATO recovery action, and trying to juggle overdue accounts, the business finally had a structured plan in place. Staff could keep working, suppliers could be managed properly, and the pressure eased enough for the business to focus on trading again.
When you are constantly behind, having some room to move changes everything.
Why Directors Should Get Advice Earlier
One of the biggest mistakes directors make is waiting too long to ask for help. A lot of business owners assume they need to hold out until things become completely unmanageable before speaking with an Insolvency Practitioner. In reality, earlier advice usually means more business insolvency options are still available.
A company dealing with tax debt today may still qualify for a Small Business Restructure. Legal action may not yet have started. Personal exposure risks may still be manageable. Once those problems start stacking together, the room to restructure becomes much smaller.
That does not mean every business can be saved. Some businesses are no longer viable and need to be wound down properly. But many directors wait far too long before finding out what options are actually available to them.
If your business is struggling with tax debt and you need practical ATO Debt Help before the situation escalates further, Mackay Goodwin’s guide to ATO payment plans and business debt is worth reviewing.
Serious Debt Does Not Always Mean the Business Is Finished
When business debt keeps growing, it becomes easy to assume the outcome is already decided. That was almost the case here. If Jack had waited much longer, the business likely would have missed the eligibility window for a Small Business Restructure altogether. Instead, the company moved early enough to deal with the superannuation issue, remain eligible, and present a proposal creditors were prepared to accept.
It was not a magic fix. The business still had to trade its way forward and stick to the repayment arrangement. But the restructure gave the company breathing room and a realistic chance to keep operating. For directors dealing with creditor pressure, growing ATO debt, or ongoing cash flow problems, getting advice early can make a major difference to the options still available.
Get in touch
Speak to one of our experts now for a free consultation. Enter your details below or call 02 8001 6520.